From: Jerry Levy (Gerald_A_Levy@MSN.COM)
Date: Sun Nov 20 2005 - 23:51:47 EST
Hi Howard, I guess I must have misunderstood a number of points of your posts. I apologize. -------------------------------------------------------------------- JERRY: That is, there is a different role for chance and surprise depending on the level of abstraction of the analysis, i.e. as we proceed to reconstruct a subject matter in thought the role of chance which is often assumed not to exist except as potential at a more abstract level of abstraction, must be considered when we analyze a phenomena in its most concrete, specific form. END QUOTE. If it's legitimate for me to substitute "surprise" for "chance" in your second use of the word "chance", I'm interested in what it means for surprise (or chance) to exist only "as potential at a more abstract level of abstraction." This is interesting. ------------------------------------------------------------------- Thanks for the question. What I meant by that is that when assumptions are made at one level of abstraction which treat variables as if they were constant then one has created the potential for "surprise" at a more concrete level of abstraction. In assuming a variable to be constant, within the context of a layered presentation of a subject matter, one has already created a condition where there is a potential for surprise. Now, I suppose you could ask whether the 'surprise' in the presentation is a 'real surprise' for the author or just a surprise for the 'reader'. I think it _should be_ the case that if one has already thought out the whole of the subject matter before writing, then the only surprises should be for readers. But, this is not always the case with authors. I doubt that it was the case totally with Marx's political economy. Even when one thinks one knows what one wants to say and how it all fits together before putting pen to paper, there are often some surprises that occur for authors in the writing process. Maybe there are many of you that have had such 'surprises'. If so, I'd love to hear about them. In solidarity, Jerry
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Tue Nov 22 2005 - 00:00:02 EST