[OPE-L:7014] Re: Re: Re: Capital & Class

From: Francisco Paulo Cipolla (cipolla@sociais.ufpr.br)
Date: Thu Apr 18 2002 - 15:45:56 EDT


Does anybody know how many times the word "cavalleria" appears in Don Quijote?
Well, it is totally irrelevant for the whole book is about that.
Paulo Cipolla.

Christopher Arthur wrote:

> MEGA 5 the first ed of the German has 45 references in its index, and that
> is not counting working-class, middle-class etc. And for MEGA 9 which is
> Moore and Aveling they give 49. Their indexing is not reliable for they
> always over-index by including in this case 'workmen' etc.
> Chris
> >In [7009] Geert wrote:
> >
> >> Relevant is also the Vol I number.
> >
> >By my reckoning:
> >
> >The total # in VI:  25. Of these *l9* are in the body of the
> >work ( 2 references are in the table of contents; and
> >there are l reference each in the l867 and l872 Prefaces
> >and the l873 Afterward. There is also a reference in the
> >l886 Preface by Engels but I have not included it in the total.)
> >
> >The breakdown/chapter is as follows:  *one reference each*
> >in  Chapters 5-6, 9-ll, l4-l7, 23-30, 32-33.  Thus, despite
> >the reference to 'class'  in l9 chapters, there is  *no* chapter in
> >which  class was mentioned in more than one excerpt.
> >
> >Of course, it may be that the # is different if we look at the
> >German (or perhaps other translations:  the online version used
> >the Moore & Aveling translation.)
> >
> >In solidarity, Jerry
>
> 17 Bristol Road, Brighton, BN2 1AP, England



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Thu May 02 2002 - 00:00:09 EDT