From: Simon Mohun (s.mohun@QMUL.AC.UK)
Date: Fri Oct 26 2007 - 11:08:20 EDT
Thanks to Dogan for the attachment. When Roberto and I wrote our note, C&C imposed a length constraint of about 1000 words - we went over a bit but after some cutting were just under 1650 words. (Having accepted the note, C&C then lost it for about 9 months, which explains the time delay in its appearance.) Having quickly read the latest Freeman and Kliman piece, I think the polemical tone, the imputations made and implications drawn are a little disappointing. And I cannot imagine how such a piece can advance the cause of progressive scholarship in any respect (probably just a failure of my imagination). Anyway, these are just personal opinions. I will read the article more closely whan I have some time, even though I'm not sure I could honestly recommend anyone else to. Simon Dogan Goecmen wrote: > I do not know much about the debate we are having. However, I asked > the authors to allow me to forward the paper attached to the list. > > I am hoping to make a contribution to the debate though I do not want > to get involved since I am under time pressure. > > > > Dogan > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > Bei AOL gibt's jetzt kostenlos eMail für alle! Was es sonst noch > umsonst bei AOL gibt, finden Sie hier heraus *AOL.de* > <http://www.aol.de>.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Wed Oct 31 2007 - 00:00:20 EDT