[OPE-L:1774] Re: Accumulation of capital in Ch. 24, V1

chaion lee (conlee@chonnam.chonnam.ac.kr)
Sun, 14 Apr 1996 05:43:48 -0700

[ show plain text ]

Paul wrote in [1770]
--------------------

At 21:57 13/04/96 -0700, glevy@acnet.pratt.edu wrote:

>===========================================================================
>*Value*: the socially necessary labor time represented in a commodity by
>its production.
>===========================================================================

Paul C
------
This parses oddly. It implies that production is a process of representation.

Chai-on
------
When Jerry said "represented", it meant that a labor time was represented by a commodity value (or by a commodity's market value). If a commodity value is to be determined by labor time, then the labor time must be represented in the commodity value.>
So, to be honestly with you, Jerry's definition was a tautological. It cannot be a definition. *Value*: the socially necessary labor time represented in a commodity value. Represented labor time: a commodity value. These cannot be definitions.

Chai-on