>
>This issue has been much debated. Opponents of the FRP have shown that
> if valuation is simultaneous, Marx is wrong. Okishio, e.g., shows
> that the zero-wage (or maximum) rate of profit falls as Marx says, but
> the stationary-price equalized rate rises, if the actual real wage is
> constant and tech change is viable. The TSS refutations of the Okishio
> theorem show that Marx is right, if total price is determined by labor
> time and thus unit prices, instead of being stationary, change with
> changes in productivity.
>
>
>Andrew Kliman
>
Paul C
------
Can I have a point of clarification Andrew. In your refutation of
Okishio do you assume a zero wage, or a constant real wage?
Paul Cockshott
wpc@cs.strath.ac.uk
http://www.cs.strath.ac.uk/CS/Biog/wpc/index.html