Re Jerry 5002: >Is there anyone else who believes that I have made a "false charge" against >Andrew? On- or off-list responses would be appreciated. Jerry: I think it's frequent your posts commenting on Andrew's give him very little credit. In fact, sometimes I feel you think Andrew is simply a dogmatic and not a serious researcher on Marx's work. Your comments to him have often a dismissive tone that cannot be welcomed for a person researching on these topics for more than 20 years and has an impressive record of published and "unpublished" (I'm thinking how many posts has Andrew contributed to ope-l!) writings. However controversial Andrew's positions he has stimulated a lot the discussion on value theory in last years. This of course is only my personal impression but I'd appreciate very much if you give some consideration to it. Alejandro R. > >In solidarity, Jerry > >
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Thu Mar 01 2001 - 14:01:39 EST