Ajit Sinha asserted (falsely) in OPE-L 3919 that "it can be proven that positive profit is possible if and only if there is positive surplus value (see Wolfstetter, 1973; Morishima, 1973, Morishima and Catephores, 1978)." This statement is just plain false. What he says can be proven has NOT been proven and CANNOT be proven. As I have stated and demonstrated numerous times (see most recently OPE-L 3616), this alleged Fundamental "Marxian" Theorem of the simultaneists has been disproved. No one has been able to refute the disproof. A forthcoming paper (by me) in _Capital and Class_, "Simultaneous Valuation vs the Exploitation Theory of Profit," will make the disproof known to the world at large. I would like to know what Ajit Sinha intends to do to correct his error. Andrew Kliman
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue Oct 31 2000 - 00:00:08 EST